Key West’s beloved Red Barn Theatre kicked off its 2024-25 season in spectacular fashion with a brilliant production that opened on December 18th, 2024. Nestled in the heart of downtown Key West, this intimate venue once again proves why it remains a cornerstone of the island’s thriving arts scene. With a witty script, razor-sharp direction, and an ensemble cast that brings life and laughter to the stage, this latest production is a must-see.
The Red Barn Theatre has long been known for its ability to bring world-class productions to life in an intimate setting, and this latest show is no exception. The talented cast and crew come together seamlessly to deliver a rich, entertaining performance that is sure to leave audiences both in stitches and reflective.
The Storyline and Cast Performances
Leading the cast is David Black, who gives a charmingly nuanced performance as Charlie Baker. Black’s portrayal of the socially awkward protagonist, who is thrust into an unusual and uproarious situation, is both endearing and comical. His comedic timing is impeccable, keeping the audience engaged as Charlie navigates his way through a series of misunderstandings that are central to the plot. Black’s ability to transition from the introverted, bumbling Charlie to moments of unsuspecting authority makes for an incredibly satisfying arc. His performance is the heart of the production, and he plays it with skillful subtlety and humor.
Opposite him is Annie Minor as Betty Meeks, the sweet-natured innkeeper who unwittingly becomes involved in Charlie’s charade. Minor brings warmth and humor to the role, creating a loveable character that anchors the chaos around her. Her interactions with Charlie and the other characters are not only hilarious but also filled with a quiet sincerity that makes her character deeply relatable.
Brian Robinson takes on the role of Foggy LeSueur, and his lively, boisterous presence on stage injects a dynamic energy into every scene he’s in. Robinson has a natural comedic flair that is a perfect match for this character. His chemistry with the rest of the ensemble helps maintain the fast-paced humor and brings out the best in his fellow actors.
Meanwhile, Chase Naylor shines as Reverend David Marshal Lee. Naylor’s portrayal of the reverend offers both charm and a hint of mystery. He navigates the complexities of the character with finesse, balancing the reverend’s good intentions with his underlying motives, which add layers to the plot. His scenes opposite Cassidy Timms, who plays Catherine Timms, are particularly engaging.
Speaking of Cassidy Timms, she is a standout as Catherine, the vibrant and sharp-tongued character who adds a splash of fiery energy to the mix. Timms’ performance is confident and assured, with an ability to deliver biting dialogue and physical comedy with ease. Her stage presence is magnetic, drawing the audience’s attention in every scene she’s a part of.
Thomas Masat as Owen Musser plays the perfect antagonist, bringing a menacing energy to the production. Masat is convincing in his portrayal of the conniving character, and his moments of confrontation with Charlie and the rest of the cast add just the right amount of tension to the otherwise lighthearted proceedings.
Lastly, Ian Wilcox delivers a delightful performance as Ellard Simms, the lovable but slow-witted member of the ensemble. Wilcox’s comedic timing and physical humor are spot-on, earning some of the biggest laughs of the night. His portrayal of Ellard brings heart to the production, and his scenes with Charlie are particularly touching and humorous.
Stunning Production Design
While the cast takes center stage, the production’s technical aspects deserve high praise as well. The set design by Gary McDonald, with co-designer Jack McDonald, creates the perfect backdrop for the unfolding antics. The set transports the audience to the rustic, cozy inn where much of the action takes place. Attention to detail is evident in every corner, from the realistic furniture to the charming props that fill the stage, thanks to Nancy 3 Hoffman.
Lighting design by Jack McDonald complements the set beautifully, enhancing the mood of each scene without overwhelming the action. Whether it’s the warm glow of morning light or the dramatic shadows cast in moments of tension, McDonald’s lighting choices are spot on, adding a layer of atmosphere that brings the play’s setting to life.
Carman Rodriquez’s costume design is also worth noting. Each character’s attire not only suits their personality but also serves as an extension of their role within the story. From the understated simplicity of Charlie’s outfits to the more colorful and distinctive costumes worn by other characters, Rodriquez’s choices are both practical and thematically appropriate.
A Triumph in Direction and Execution
A huge part of the success of this production comes down to the thoughtful direction and tight pacing. The Red Barn Theatre has once again curated a show that captures the essence of its intimate space while delivering performances that feel grand. The direction keeps the audience engaged, expertly balancing moments of high comedy with quieter, more emotional beats.
The camaraderie among the cast is palpable, with each actor playing off the others’ strengths. The humor is both verbal and physical, making full use of the small space without feeling cramped. The comedic timing is so well-executed that even the most outlandish moments feel grounded in the characters’ realities.
Final Thoughts and Ticket Information
This latest production at the Red Barn Theatre is not to be missed. With an outstanding cast, beautiful production design, and expert direction, it’s a show that will leave audiences laughing and thoroughly entertained. Whether you’re a local or visiting Key West, this is a theater experience worth making time for.
The Red Barn Theatre is located at 319 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040. Performances are expected to run through early February 2025, but tickets are sure to sell out quickly. To reserve your spot, visit the theater’s official website or call their box office at (305) 296-9911. Online reservations are also available @ https://keystix.com/
No Comment